6 Reasons Why a Smaller Engagement Ring Might be Perfect for You

by | Apr 21, 2023

On the brink of a proposal? Need some compelling arguments for opting for a smaller engagement ring rather than a large one?

Despite popular beliefs, it isn’t always about the size. Rather, it’s all about what resonates with your personal style, what you’ll feel comfortable donning, and what you’d be proud to wear as a symbol of your love.

If you’re yet to purchase the ring, we encourage you to check out our guide on How to Find the Perfect Engagement Ring, and also have a look at our Top Diamond Jewelry Retailer Comparison Guide.

There are certain signs that indicate a smaller diamond might be a more fitting choice for your engagement ring. Let’s dive into some of these.

1. You’re Saving for Future Expenses

Begin your marital journey debt-free!

Perhaps you’re someone who envisions a bigger picture beyond the sparkling adornment on your finger. If you have future plans and getting a larger diamond would interfere or delay those, it’s not imperative to opt for a diamond that exceeds your current one in size.

Considering that marriage is a partnership, starting off your shared life in debt for a ring that overshoots your budget may not be the wisest decision.

Check out our guide on How to Craft the Perfect Marriage Proposal!

It could be that you’re looking to allocate funds for your grand wedding day, an unforgettable honeymoon, or a dream home. Opting for a smaller diamond is a testament to your practicality and financial astuteness.

2. Making Other People Jealous isn’t Your Thing

Women have often reveled in showcasing their rings and the impressive gems they carry (well, not always, but most times).

This can sometimes fuel feelings of envy or dissatisfaction with your own romantic circumstances, thereby putting undue stress on your partner and your relationship.

If you’re someone who finds no appeal in such comparisons, and does not link the size of your diamond to the depth of your fiancé’s love, go for a size that brings you joy.

Ultimately, you might show off your ring to others once or twice, but you’re the one who’ll be looking at it day in and day out. Your contentment is what truly matters.

So, always remember, it’s about you and your loved one, not the rest of the world.

3. You’re not a Big Fan of Diamonds

While this might not resonate with many women – after all, a diamond is traditionally said to be a girl’s best friend – some individuals simply don’t have a fondness for it (lucky you, if your lady belongs to this rare category).

In that case, you could either choose another piece of jewelry, or opt for a smaller diamond. After all, you do need something to propose with!

If you’re keen on sporting one of the emerging engagement ring trends, you might want to focus on a distinctive metal or design that holds special meaning for you, rather than dwelling on the size of the diamond.

4. You’re not Comfortable Being the Center of Attention

In some cases, sporting a large engagement ring can seem out of place in the workplace and can even prove to be a hindrance in your daily tasks. In certain cities, you may feel uncomfortable wearing a prominent stone while traversing the streets or subway stations.

For instance, if you work as a public defender or in a restaurant, both the size and the grandeur of your ring could draw unwarranted attention towards you.

Some individuals simply prefer to maintain a low profile and not be the focal point, even at social gatherings. They enjoy blending into the background instead of constantly being in the limelight.

5. Quality vs Size

One benefit of wearing a smaller engagement ring is that you’re able to buy a better quality diamond, which is something people seem struggle to understand.

It’s not always about getting a larger diamond if you want it to be remarkable, you can get a 0.7 carat diamond that looks way more beautiful than a 2 carat diamonds.

That’s because getting an excellent cut is the most important factor in determining diamond’s beauty, not the carat, and that’s why cut is the most important factor among the 4Cs.

When your budget is limited, many people forget that a smaller, more perfect diamond might be the better choice than a larger flawed one.

Bigger flawed rings can be seen from afar and only invites unwanted commentary as it can’t be conveniently hidden. This applies to color, cut, and clarity. No one wants to walk around with a cloudy-looking large rock that will draw everyone’s attention for the wrong reason.

6. Less Obvious to Potential Thieves

While large rings have a certain allure due to their sparkle, it can sometimes prove disadvantageous.

Flashing a massive engagement ring around could potentially attract the attention of thieves. This holds particularly true if you are traveling or residing in an area that’s susceptible to crime.

On the other hand, a small ring is less likely to draw attention, thereby enhancing your safety.


Choosing an engagement ring is a deeply personal and meaningful decision.

While large diamonds can certainly be impressive, they aren’t the right choice for everyone. Opting for a smaller ring can often be a more pragmatic and comfortable choice.

It can reflect your unique style, adhere to your financial plans, and also ensure your safety in certain environments.

Moreover, a smaller, higher quality diamond can often be more appealing than a larger, flawed one. Ultimately, the value of an engagement ring isn’t in its size, but in the love it symbolizes.

Always choose a ring that best suits your lifestyle, comfort, and personal preferences. Remember, the best ring is one that you’ll love wearing every day.


  • Olivia Bennett - Diamonds Expert

    Olivia Bennett is a dynamic and accomplished expert in the diamond industry. With over a decade of experience, she has established herself as a go-to authority for all things diamonds. Olivia's love affair with these exquisite gemstones began in her childhood and has only grown stronger over the years. Having worked closely with diamond miners, manufacturers, and retailers, Olivia possesses a comprehensive understanding of every aspect of the industry. From diamond grading to sourcing and the latest design trends, her expertise is unparalleled. Clients value her impeccable taste, attention to detail, and personalized approach. Driven by a passion for education and empowerment, Olivia launched her own website dedicated to diamonds. Through engaging and informative content, she guides individuals through the intricacies of diamond buying, helping them make confident and informed decisions. Olivia's mission is to ensure that everyone finds their perfect diamond, one that truly reflects their unique desires. With her extensive knowledge and unwavering dedication, Olivia is a trusted guide in the dazzling world of diamonds.

Related Posts